A new ‘FA Shield’ would level playing field for Step 3 and 4 sides

Currently it’s unlikely any of Berkshire’s FA Vase finalists will be making a return to Wembley
Could a new FA Shield in between the FA Trophy and FA Vase level the playing field for Step 3 and 4 clubs?
Could a new FA Shield in between the FA Trophy and FA Vase level the playing field for Step 3 and 4 clubs?

Anyone who follows football locally in Berkshire will be well aware of what a great competition the FA Vase is. Thatcham Town were winners in 2018, Binfield reached the final in 2021 and most recently Ascot United took home the famous trophy last summer. We’ve also had clubs such as Bracknell Town make the latter stages of the competition and play in some real nerve jangling games.

Whilst Thatcham, Binfield and Ascot were excellent Step 5 sides before their promotion to Step 4, their current opportunities of reaching Wembley in the FA Trophy seem very unlikely. The FA Vase encompasses all Step 5 and 6 clubs but the FA Trophy takes in sides from four separate steps from the National League down to Step 4. It’s very tough for clubs at the level that Binfield or Thatcham play at to compete with former league clubs with professional setups like Chesterfield or even the likes of Maidenhead United.

“Wembley is the jewel in England football’s crown and should belong to everyone from the national team down to the grassroots”

Kai Walters celebrates. Photo: Neil Graham.
Kai Walters celebrates. Photo: Neil Graham.

With that in mind, is it worth adding a third national competition? An FA Shield for clubs at Step 3 and Step 4? This would surely benefit National League clubs who would see a smaller cup competition and fewer games as they “concentrate on the league” as well as clubs at Step 3 and 4 who would have the carrot of a Wembley Final to look forward to.

Wembley is the jewel in England football’s crown and should belong to everyone from the national team down to the grassroots. It’s important that the men’s and women’s national teams play there, show-piece cup finals, playoffs and of course grassroots cup competitions. England’s football pyramid is easily the best in the world, no other country comes close. Let’s nurture it by allowing more of its clubs a chance at playing at its greatest venue.

This article appeared first in the Football in Berkshire Friday newsletter. To get your regular dose of Berkshire football news and stories in your inbox, click here to subscribe.

Football in Berkshire is looking for new talent. If you love your grassroots football, or have dreamed of being a football reporter, take a look at the opportunities available here.

Upcoming fixtures

Saturday 19th September 2026

Bracknell Town15:00Havant & Waterlooville
Maidenhead United15:00Ebbsfleet United
Slimbridge15:00Hungerford Town
Show all fixtures

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join the new Football in Berkshire Supporters Club

If you love what we do, we’re delighted to announce there is now a way to support Football in Berkshire! For as little as £2 a month, you can support us and receive rewards, including invites to our Supporters Club events, pin badges and t-shirts.

Football in Berkshire averages 12,000 readers per month according to Google Analytics.